Russian agricultural market under threat as Belarusian equipment gains advantage - domestic producers raise concerns

The Clash of Agricultural Giants: Belarus vs. Russia

Russian agricultural market under threat as Belarusian equipment gains advantage - domestic producers raise concerns

Konstantin Babkin, president of the "Rosspetsmash" association and co-owner of the combine-harvesting enterprise "Rostselmash," raises concerns about a significant drop in sales of Russian agricultural machinery and the growth of Belarusian producers.

In an interview, Babkin links the waning sales of Russian agricultural machinery to an imminent crisis, primarily due to the aggressive expansion of Belarusian producers. This escalation stems largely from the exploitation of state subsidies by Belarusian manufacturers.

Farmers in Russia can secure preferential loans from any local bank, while Belarus compensates them for 15% of the annual interest rate. On the other hand, commercial rates for Russian machinery reach 30%, with no annual subsidies provided. This discrepancy sets an unbalanced stage, allowing Belarusian competitors to seize a prominent share in the market.

As a result, Belarusian producers have expanded their presence: their market share jumped from 17% in 2021 to a staggering 40% by 2024. Under normal circumstances, Babkin believes, the ratio should be 75% to 25% in favor of Russian companies.

To alleviate this issue, Babkin proposes two potential solutions: either negotiating common subsidy rules with Belarus or increasing the budget for the Russian program of preferential loans (No1432). At present, 10 billion rubles are allocated, but the need is 20 billion rubles.

Inside the Battlefield

1. Subsidy Disparities: Belarusian manufacturers profit from subsidies that make their machinery significantly less expensive for Russian farmers, creating an unfair advantage [1].
2. Market Access: Leveraging Russia's banking infrastructure, Belarusian firms offer competitively priced loans, rapidly penetrating the market [1].
3. Manufacturing Specialization: Belarus has long focused on heavy machinery, a specialty supported by Soviet-era infrastructure [3].

The Aftermath

• Market Share Shifts: Belarusian combines have captured a growing share of the Russian market, eroding the dominance of Russian manufacturers [1].
• Profitability Pressures: Russian producers report steep sales declines (-30% YoY in early 2025), attributing the problem largely to unequal competition [1].
• Regional Trade Dynamics: This expansion risks exacerbating trade imbalances between Belarus and Russia, highlighting flaws in Russia's subsidy policies [1][3].

Potential Cures

1. Subsidy Parity: Equalizing loan subsidy programs to match Belarusian competitors' price structures [1].
2. Import Restrictions: Imposing temporary tariffs or quotas on Belarusian machinery to protect domestic producers, although this risks violating Eurasian Economic Union agreements [3].
3. Industrial Modernization: Investing in Russian production efficiency to match Belarusian cost structures [3].
4. Diplomatic Negotiations: Revising bilateral agreements to ensure fair competition within shared economic frameworks [1].

Last Call: Belarus’s subsidy-driven strategy has upended Russia’s agricultural machinery sector, necessitating policy adjustments to ensure the stability and competitiveness of domestic producers.

1. The subsidies provided by the Belarusian government to their agricultural machinery manufacturers are making their machinery significantly cheaper for Russian farmers, creating an unfair advantage that sabotages the sales of Russian agricultural machinery.
2. The aggressive expansion of Belarusian producers across the Russian market is primarily fueled by their exploitation of state subsidies, a practice that sets an imbalanced stage in their favor.
3. In response to the declining sales of Russian agricultural machinery, Konstantin Babkin has proposed negotiating common subsidy rules with Belarus or increasing the budget for the Russian program of preferential loans to match Belarusian subsidies.
4. To address the escalating dominance of Belarusian competitors in the Russian market, potential solutions include equalizing loan subsidy programs, imposing temporary tariffs or quotas on Belarusian machinery, investing in Russian production efficiency, and revisiting bilateral agreements to ensure fair competition within shared economic frameworks.

Read also: