Is the future uncertain for the U.S. currency?

Is the future uncertain for the U.S. currency?

In the world of finance, a significant shift is underway as the era of low risk and high returns from unhedged dollar exposure appears to be drawing to a close. Aaron Hurd, senior portfolio manager at State Street Investment Management, has made this assertion, pointing towards a future where alternative currencies might challenge the dollar's global hegemony.

One such potential contender is the Chinese renminbi. Central banks are increasingly holding renminbi, yet its rise is slowed by structural barriers such as capital controls, limited market openness, and geopolitical tensions.

Central bank digital currencies (CBDCs) are another intriguing prospect. They offer the potential to reduce reliance on the dollar by streamlining cross-border payments. However, regulatory uncertainties and market fragmentation have kept them peripheral in reserve management for now.

Stablecoins, while better suited for payments than Bitcoin, have a much smaller market and have yet to seriously challenge the dollar’s primacy.

A multipolar currency system, involving several major currencies like the euro and yuan, is also envisioned by experts. This system could potentially combine commodity backing (gold or baskets of commodities) and regional currency zones, reminiscent of earlier historical currency arrangements.

De-dollarization efforts by countries like Russia, Iran, Brazil, and India aim to bypass dollar-based sanctions and reduce dependence on the U.S. financial system. However, these alternatives are often clunky and limited compared to the established dollar infrastructure.

Despite these challenges, the dollar remains unrivaled in terms of liquidity, depth, and global acceptance. The transition to a new system could be gradual and complex, likely involving a hybrid and multipolar arrangement over years or even decades.

Yara Aziz, Senior Economist at OMFIF, poses the question of what alternatives might fill the gap if the dollar's status weakens, but for the time being, the options remain limited. Massimiliano Castelli, head of strategy and advice at UBS Asset Management, highlights uncertainty through recent UBS survey data, showing that 47% of reserve managers fear a deterioration in the quality and independence of US economic data.

On the other hand, Mark Sobel, US chair at OMFIF, cautions against writing off the dollar too quickly, suggesting that short-term market movements are being mistaken for structural change.

The euro is seen as a potential beneficiary of global macroeconomic and geopolitical shifts over the next five years, with 74% of the same survey respondents believing so. However, for the euro to rise, Europe needs to deliver on meaningful institutional reform, as argued by Pierpaolo Benigno, professor of monetary economics at the University of Bern, and Edoardo Reviglio, visiting senior research scholar at Yale Law School.

Gold has reclaimed its role as a core reserve asset due to its independence from any single sovereign and its reliability as a hedge against volatility and geopolitical risk. This is according to Michael Paulus, head of public sector banking, Asia, Alberto Torres, head of public sector banking, LATAM, Sunil Kaushik, head of precious metals solutions, APAC, Natalie Tsui, and Tobias Cheung, public sector banking, Asia at Citi.

The focus is shifting towards managing the risks around the dollar more deliberately and being prepared for what might come next. Geoffrey Yu, senior EMEA markets strategist at BNY, argues that talk of comprehensive liquidation of and diversification away from US assets is marginal at best.

In Japan, investors are under pressure to develop concrete investment strategies as de-dollarisation accelerates. Jesper Koll, global ambassador and expert director, Monex Group, Japan, argues that a weaker yen, shifting geostrategic dynamics, and a more confident stance from domestic leadership are putting Japan back in the spotlight.

The OMFIF Bulletin brings together perspectives on the reassessment of allocation strategies due to trends driving a reassessment of the dollar's dominance. Christopher Smart, managing partner of Arbroath Group, considers digital assets as a geopolitical risk accelerant, intersecting with political populism and weakening trust in institutions, particularly in the US.

In conclusion, while the dollar's dominance is being questioned, no fully credible alternative has yet emerged to match its liquidity, depth, and global acceptance. The transition to a new system could be a complex process, involving a hybrid and multipolar arrangement over years or even decades.

1. In the finance world, there is a significant shift occurring, with the era of low risk and high returns from unhedged dollar exposure potentially coming to an end.
2. Aaron Hurd, senior portfolio manager at State Street Investment Management, has suggested that alternative currencies, such as the Chinese renminbi, might challenge the dollar's global hegemony.
3. Central bank digital currencies (CBDCs) could reduce reliance on the dollar by streamlining cross-border payments, but regulatory uncertainties and market fragmentation have kept them sidelined for now.
4. Stablecoins, while better suited for payments than Bitcoin, have a much smaller market and have yet to significantly challenge the dollar’s primacy.
5. A multipolar currency system, involving major currencies like the euro and yuan, is envisioned by experts, potentially combining commodity backing and regional currency zones.
6. Despite the challenges, de-dollarization efforts by countries like Russia, Iran, Brazil, and India aim to bypass dollar-based sanctions and reduce dependence on the U.S. financial system, but their alternatives are often clunky and limited compared to the established dollar infrastructure.
7. Gold has reclaimed its role as a core reserve asset due to its independence from any single sovereign and its reliability as a hedge against volatility and geopolitical risk.

Read also: