Skip to content

Insurer-Agent Collaboration Strains Amid Tighter Standards, Agents Shop Around

Tighter standards challenge insurer-agent collaboration. Top carriers with high agent satisfaction may gain preferred status as agents shop around for clients.

In this image, we can see an advertisement contains a car and some text.
In this image, we can see an advertisement contains a car and some text.

Insurer-Agent Collaboration Strains Amid Tighter Standards, Agents Shop Around

Insurance agents are grappling with more stringent collaboration with insurers due to tighter underwriting standards and less flexible onboarding processes. Meanwhile, agents are increasingly exploring options for clients' coverage, potentially favoring carriers with high agent satisfaction ratings.

The 2024 U.S. Independent Agent Satisfaction Study by J.D. Power indicates that commercial lines satisfaction has hit an all-time high of 781, surpassing personal lines satisfaction for the first time. Independent agents reported high satisfaction with their carrier partners, especially in commercial real estate lines.

Top-rated carriers maintain strong relationships with agents by providing robust quoting tools, regular communication, and incentives. These carriers may become preferred partners in competitive markets, reducing switching risk. However, the top three highest-rated companies in the study were not listed in the available search results.

Erie Insurance ranked highest for personal lines with a score of 862, while Auto-Owners Insurance topped commercial lines with a score of 844. Agents are proactively exploring different carriers for clients due to better coverage options or lower rates, making insurer-agent collaboration more challenging.

While stricter underwriting standards and less flexible onboarding processes pose challenges to insurer-agent collaboration, carriers demonstrating strong agent satisfaction may benefit. Proactive support from carriers can foster preferred partnerships, reducing switching risk in competitive markets. The 2024 U.S. Independent Agent Satisfaction Study emphasizes the importance of robust quoting tools, communication, and incentives in maintaining strong agent relationships.

Read also:

Latest