Debating Investment Strategies: Active vs. Passive Fund Management - Which Performs Better?
================================================================================
Over the past decade in India, index funds have generally outperformed actively managed mutual funds, especially in large-cap categories, while actively managed funds have shown higher variability in performance and risks.
Performance
A large majority (70-80%) of actively managed large-cap funds underperformed the corresponding benchmark index, S&P BSE 100, over recent years. Similarly, mid-cap active funds have also shown increasing underperformance against indices like the Nifty Midcap 150. This suggests that selecting consistently outperforming active funds is uncertain and somewhat coincidental.
On the other hand, index funds, such as those tracking the Nifty 50 or the broader Nifty 500, have delivered returns comparable to the overall market, benefiting from broad diversification and low expense ratios. For example, Nifty 50 index funds represent the top 50 companies and cover about 62% of market capitalization, providing stable long-term growth.
Active funds can sometimes deliver superior returns by targeting less popular or off-index stocks, especially in volatile or uncertain market conditions, where active management agility adds value. However, the consistency of active funds’ outperformance is low.
Risk
Active funds often carry higher risk due to concentrated bets on selected stocks or sectors, especially in mid-cap and small-cap segments, which can be more volatile and less liquid. Index funds, on the other hand, inherently reduce unsystematic risk by diversification across many stocks and sectors.
Active funds offer the ability to manage risk dynamically, such as adjusting exposure based on geopolitical or market developments, which can be beneficial in turbulent times. However, this dynamic management comes with its own set of risks.
Advantages Comparison
| Aspect | Actively Managed Funds | Index Funds | |----------------------|------------------------------------------------|-----------------------------------------------| | Cost | Higher expense ratios due to active management | Lower expense ratios, cost-effective | | Returns | Potentially higher but inconsistent | Stable, consistent long-term returns tracking market performance | | Risk | Higher; concentrated portfolios possible | Lower; broad diversification | | Flexibility | Can adjust holdings based on market views | Tied to index composition, passive | | Ease of Investing| Requires fund selection expertise | Easy, no stock picking required, good for beginners | | Suitability | Investors seeking above-average returns and willing to accept higher risk | Investors preferring steady growth and low cost |
Summary
For most Indian investors over the past decade, especially in large and mid-cap equity segments, index funds have outperformed active funds in terms of risk-adjusted returns due to lower costs, diversification, and transparency. Active funds may add value in specific market conditions or niches but are generally less consistent and higher risk.
Therefore, for long-term wealth creation, especially for beginners and cost-conscious investors, broad-based index funds like Nifty 50 or Nifty 500 are advantageous, whereas active funds may suit risk-tolerant investors seeking tactical opportunities.
The global data on active vs passive funds shows that the win-loss ratio of about 1:2 i.e. about 66% of actively managed funds underperform the index funds. The DSP NIFTY 50 Index Fund, for example, replicates the structure of the NIFTY 50 Index and holds all 50 stocks in a similar proportion. The modern mutual fund industry started in the year 1924, with the first publicly available index fund launched by the Vanguard Group in 1976.
References:
- Investopedia
- Moneycontrol
- ValueWalk
- Enhancing one's personal-finance portfolio, especially for long-term investments, can be more effective with the use of low-cost index funds, as they have generally shown outperformance over actively managed mutual funds in India's large and mid-cap equity segments.
- With personal-finance decisions being a significant part of investing, it's crucial to acknowledge that in the realm of finance, index funds, due to their low expense ratios, broad diversification, and transparency, have generally provided stable, risk-adjusted returns over the past decade in India, outperforming a majority of actively managed mutual funds.
